Valentine’s Day & Winter

You’ll find gifts, platters, and small order options. If you don’t see exactly what you are looking for, please contact Sara, to discuss how we can customize an order just for you. 

Please note, Valentine’s Day orders must be placed by Friday, February 10th. Items will be shipped by February 11th, or you can arrange for pickup, in Lexington, until February 14th.

Sara's Stuffed Cookies

A cookie with a melt-in-your mouth surprise middle.

Regular Flavors:

  • PB Cup: Peanut butter chip cookie stuffed with a dark chocolate PB Cup candy.
  • Love Filled: Chocolate chip cookie stuffed with either a Hershey’s Kiss.
  • Caramel-Licious: Snickerdoodle (cinnamon/sugar) cookie stuffed with a sea salted caramel.
  • Golden Treasure: Sprinkle sugar cookie stuffed with a mini Golden Oreo.

Seasonal Flavors:

  • Mexican Hot Chocolate: Chocolate cookie, cayenne pepper and cinnamon, stuffed with a dark chocolate Hershey’s Kiss. Topped with mini marshmallows.
  • Hot Chocolate: Chocolate cookie stuffed with a dark chocolate Hershey’s Kiss. Topped with mini marshmallows. (Mexican Hot Chocolate Cookie without the kick!)
  • Chai Spiced: Snickerdoodle (cinnamon/sugar), cinnamon, ginger, all spice, and nutmeg stuffed with a sea salted caramel (Caramel-Licious Cookie with chai spices!)
  • Fudgy Java Jolt: Espresso cookie stuffed with a dark chocolate Hershey Kiss. Topped with both white and semi-sweet chocolate drizzle.

Grab and Go Bags

Individually wrapped. Sold in packs of 6. Minimum: 2 bags/12 cookies.

Care Packages/Gifts

Shipping is in MA only. For shipping outside of MA, contact me. Additional shipping fees apply. $10 for items under $45; $15 for items over $45.

  • No Frills Mailer: 18 individually wrapped Stuffed Cookies packaged and ready to mail. Select up to three flavors, minimum of 6 cookies /flavor. 
  • Valentine Gift Boxes: Adorable Valentine gift box filled with 12 individually wrapped Stuffed Cookies. Select up to two flavors, minimum of 6 cookies/flavor. 
  • Box of Cookies Wrapped in Ribbons: Bakery box filled with 24 individually wrapped, Stuffed Cookies, tied up in ribbons. Select up to four flavors, minimum of 6 cookies/flavor.
  • Cookie Monster Club: Initially, a glass jar, filled with 12 stuffed cookies, will be sent, in February Then, for the following three months (March, April, and May) an additional package of 12 Stuffed Cookies will be sent. Your recipient will love getting 4-months of homemade cookies delivered to his/her door. 


Delicious, rich bundt cake, topped with chocolate glaze, in your choice of size.

Platters: Perfect for your next party or business meeting. Online, you’ll find a few popular combinations. Contact Sara to create a custom-sized platter or order online. (Platter Minimum of 12 cookies per flavor. For pickup in Lexington).

If you prefer to place an order via email, click here to download our Valentine's Day order form.